Words for my thoughts

Why An MBA???

Posted by Alok on July 13, 2007

This is the question which may have very well costed me a seat at IIMB. This is the question which most of the people preparing for their B school interviews/admission essays dread answering. This is the question which maybe the most clichéd question in any interview. This is the question which all aspirants prepare the best yet this is the question which nobody can answer perfectly.  

I may have gotten an admission to one of the IIMs, I may have worked for 2 years but I am still not very sure about the answer to this question. What I dread is that even after doing an MBA I might not be able to answer this question. And this fear is amplified after I read the book “Snapshots from hell, The making of an MBA”. The book is about the first year at Stanford Business School, a school among the top 3 business schools worldwide. The book is about the struggle to cope up with the academic rigor, to get used to the cut-throat competition, to worry of not getting a job and more importantly the struggle to survive. And finally it also tries to answer the question and it would be a lie if I say that I don’t agree with it. We will come to the answer later. First of all lets see what an MBA is and what an MBA actually is. 

So what does an MBA from XYZ school provide the graduates with? Is an MBA more of a fancy degree than some real stuff? Is the school matters more than the education itself? Will the graduates end up being at the same position 5 years down the line had they played Golf and boozed instead of learning how to run a company at the school? Will it be fair to say that all a business school does is put a higher price tag on its graduates? The answer to all these questions is YES and NO. What I feel is that an MBA is both. It makes you sellable, it creates demand for you but that demand is also right. An MBA student learns 100s of different things during the course of 2 years. He is among the crème-de-la-crème when he enters a prestigious business school. He is already one of the better brains around, so he deserves all that he gets after his graduation, every penny of it. But it is also true that an MBA is a bit overrated. It’s the experience and sweating out in the corporate battlefield which ultimately separates chaff from the wheat. Its just that the odds of an MBA being the grain are higher than being the chaff. 

Coming back to the question, Why MBA. I still don’t have an answer but I would like to quote from the book itself.  It diversifies the outlook of an individual, forces people to learn about everything ranging from IT to OB to marketing, gives people poise and self-confidence, and more than everything gives the power of networking. The contacts made during the two years last lifelong and reap rewards continuously. A business school gives an opportunity to mingle with bright, business minded classmates and to give serious thoughts to all kinds of business careers. A business school doesn’t take anyone to paradise; in fact it teaches that there isn’t a paradise.

So now, is a business school worth the effort and the investment? I have already taken a decision and till now not repenting it. So, decide for yourself…

6 Responses to “Why An MBA???”

  1. subodh Says:

    Honestly expressed ! But I still feel the question remains unanswered :)

  2. avinav Says:

    insightful alok !! i would really like you to edit/add to it in an year’s time or so.. i m sure we’ll have more of perspective then.. may b come up with 1 on life@iim.. cheers !!

  3. arustagi Says:

    Sure. Infact I am not going to wait for one year. This was pending since long, hence posted it. The new one should be coming in quick time.

  4. gabrielbcn Says:

    I don’t think anybody learns how to run a company at school. You can get analytical skills but, being a manager, that’s another thing. You can’t learn that, only improve if you’re already one.

    IMHO of course

    best regards

  5. Ashok Says:

    The question as far as I think is should not be understood as for one who is thinking of doing MBA and is asked “Why MBA?”

    But on a more fundamental level as “Why MBA at all?”

    Why not live life instead.

    Or do we intend that without MBA life is not worth living or, conversely (though not that exactly) with MBA the life is more worth living.

    The fundamental reason for us to be on this earth is (scientifically speaking) to survive and procreate.

    Rest of the reasons are invented one and keep on changing with time and age. For instance having a FERRARI is secondary reason which may be desirable in 21st Century for an Indian but may be passé in 22nd Century. Same is true for MBA. In 20th Century India (without BPO & KPO) having an MBA was not that significant. Even in the last decade of 20th Century in India being a software professional was a better option .But now MBA is. In future it may not be.

    But the fundamental reasons remain everlasting – were true for hunter-gatherers, nomads as they are for present day Homo sapiens.

    Now should we not test all our aspirations/actions on the question as to how it helps us in furthering the fundamental reasons for which we are here.

    Why is it that in India (or for that matter in large (so called) developing countries) most of the economic progress ends up in serving the developed world e.g. US and Europe? And consequently most of the labour force (yes MBA or Engineers are also part of the labour force) is trained to meet that goal. The goal of satisfying consumers in Developed world.

    Thus they (the consumers in Developed world) are having all the fun while we in developing countries are doing all those jobs which they thing beneath their dignity to do. If after doing engineering in top end colleges in India and then getting MBA tag from top end B Schools in India we end up thus, isn’t something wrong somewhere? Are we not being made suckers? And on top of that we are supposed to be happy and contended doing all that.
    Are we not in our endeavor for the so called “good life” {which is supposed to be at our feet after we end up being Engineers in top end colleges in India and then becoming MBAs from top end B Schools} giving away “life” itself? And all the time the strings are in the hands of someone sitting in US or Europe.

    And what are those westerns doing when we are slogging for them? Studying history, culture, military war games, so as to understand how to perpetuate the stranglehold that they have on us. For us study of history, society, politics, culture, military war games is strict “no no”. Why? Because it does not give you good job. But should we care for a mere job when our life and the life of our future generations is at stake?

  6. Alok Says:

    @ Ashok: Nice comments and i would tend to agree with you. BTW, ur background?

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>